CHARACTER CODE in practice · Leadership
How to Turn a Leadership Disagreement into a Better Decision
Written by Atlas SalemChief of Staff · Salem Family & Mindshare VenturesOriginally published October 8, 2026 · 4-minute read
A leadership disagreement can leave everyone more certain of what they thought before the meeting. The conversation ends, a decision gets made, and the assumptions underneath it remain largely untouched.
How might we use that same conversation to improve our thinking?
In Deliberation Over Debate, Bassam Salem explored the value of entering a difficult conversation with a willingness to refine our own position. Here is a practical way to bring that question into a team discussion.
Begin with a decision worth examining
Choose one real decision: whether to launch a product, change a process, hire for a role, or continue an initiative. Keep the question narrow enough that the group can make progress.
Write down your current recommendation before the discussion begins. Then add the reason you find most convincing. This creates something specific to revisit when the conversation is over.
For example: “We should launch next month because we need customer feedback.” That is a useful starting position. It also contains assumptions about readiness, the quality of the feedback, and the cost of getting something wrong.
Ask three questions before defending your answer
1. What am I assuming?
Separate what you know from what you expect. A customer has asked for a feature. That is information. The expectation that many customers will pay for it is an assumption that deserves examination.
Invite others to help identify the assumptions in your recommendation. Listen for the ones you have repeated so often that they now sound like facts.
2. What would make me reconsider?
Name a concrete observation that could change your recommendation. Would a failed test matter? A different cost estimate? Feedback from the people who will have to carry out the decision?
If no answer comes readily, pause there. It is difficult to learn from a conversation when the conclusion is closed before the conversation begins.
3. What does the other person see that I may be missing?
Before offering a rebuttal, try explaining the strongest version of the other person’s concern. Ask whether you have understood it fairly.
In the launch example, someone arguing for a delay may be worried about a support team that is already stretched. Naming that concern accurately gives the group a more useful problem to solve. It also makes room for a narrower launch, a smaller test, or a different sequence of work.
Make room for a more precise answer
A productive discussion may leave the main recommendation intact while changing an important condition. “Launch next month” might become “Launch to a small group next month, provided the support team can handle the additional work.”
That refinement deserves to be stated explicitly. Otherwise, the meeting can end with everyone claiming agreement while carrying away different understandings.
Before closing, record:
- The decision and the reasoning behind it.
- The assumption that still needs testing.
- Who will test it and when the group will revisit the result.
Ask each participant to name one thing the discussion clarified. The answer can be small. A clearer question or a better understanding of someone else’s concern can be meaningful progress.
A ten-minute exercise for your next meeting
- Two minutes: Write down your recommendation and its most important assumption.
- Four minutes: Invite someone with a different view to explain the risk they see. Summarize it back before responding.
- Three minutes: Identify what you would test, change, or add to your recommendation.
- One minute: Record the next step and the question that remains open.
Try it on a decision where disagreement is manageable. There is no need to begin with the most emotionally charged issue in the organization.
The question to carry into the room is simple: What could I understand better by the time we leave?
Keep putting character into practice.
This exercise builds on Bassam Salem’s Deliberation Over Debate. Explore CHARACTER CODE for the wider conversation about character and the long game.
For book news and reflections from Bassam, request to join the community.

Leave a Reply